Why do I always lend things and never ask for them back?
A novel left with a colleague in spring. A drill went to the neighbor. A sum of money went to a cousin "until the end of the month," and that month was a year ago. You notice the gap on the shelf every week. You have never once said: could I have it back?
Two kinds of people
In December 1820, Charles Lamb opened an essay in the London Magazine with a theory. The human species, he wrote, is made of two races: those who borrow and those who lend.
He praises the borrowers with a straight face. They are the great race, open and at ease in the world. The lenders, among whom he counts himself, are lean and suspicious, born to serve.
"What a careless, even deportment hath your borrower!"
— Charles Lamb, "The Two Races of Men", Essays of Elia (1823)
The joke is plain. The borrower is careless with other people's things, and Lamb calls it a fine bearing. Yet the envy under the joke is real; the borrower moves through a room as if it belonged to him. The lender counts his shelves.
The friend who took the folios
Halfway through, the essay stops being a theory and turns into a room. Lamb walks the reader past his bookcases and points at the holes. Here stood a tall folio of divinity. There, a book on urn burial. A volume of old plays is missing from a set, and the man responsible has a name in the essay, Comberbatch. Readers of the time knew it was Coleridge, Lamb's oldest friend.
Lamb does not ask for the books back. He describes the gaps with care, almost tenderly, and then tells the reader to keep lending to this man anyway. Coleridge returns books, when he returns them, covered in notes in his own hand. Lamb treasures the notes.
So the gap on the shelf holds two things at once. It is a loss, and it is also proof of a friendship with someone larger than oneself.
What the lender keeps
Not asking pays in its own way. The lender stays the one who gives. He never becomes the one who needs. He keeps the moral high ground and the right to a quiet grievance, and he never has to hear "I forgot" or "I can't."
Lamb, for all his mockery, chooses his race. He would rather mourn a missing folio than stand at Coleridge's door and ask for it.
What do I get from staying the one who lends, and what would I have to become, even for a minute, if I asked for it back?
Epimelea is an app built around the existential school. The conversation carries over from one meeting to the next. The archive is encrypted on the device and belongs to the person who wrote it.
About the app: an AI therapist for long-term therapy
This page is about a school of psychotherapy. It is not medical advice and not emergency help. If you are in danger right now, contact your local emergency number, or find a helpline in your country at findahelpline.com.