Library

Texts about existential and humanistic therapy: what the school works with and where it came from.

Why do I feel guilty when I'm not productive: Stevenson's «An Apology for Idlers»A day without ticked boxes can still be full. Robert Louis Stevenson asked whose list decides what counts as doing something.
Why do I feel restless even though I have everything: George Herbert, «The Pulley»The house is full and the evening is quiet, and still something will not sit down. In 1633 George Herbert wrote about the one gift God kept back.
Why do I like feeling melancholy?: KeatsA good evening, and in the middle of it a quiet ache that you would not give back. Keats wrote an ode about why that ache sits inside delight.
Why do I want things because others want them: Spinoza's EthicsYou never cared about it until a friend did. Spinoza described this pull three centuries ago, in Part III of the Ethics.
Why do I feel like my things own me: Thoreau in WaldenYou buy something to feel freer, then it needs storing, insuring and moving. Thoreau counted who carries whom.
Why do I care more about what others think than what I think: Marcus AureliusYou trust a stranger's verdict on you over your own. Marcus Aurelius noticed the same contradiction in himself.
Why do I keep comparing my life to my friends'? Plutarch on the ladder of comparisonA friend gets the job, the flat, the wedding, and your own life suddenly looks smaller. Plutarch described why the measuring never stops.
Why do I feel more alive when I have an enemy? Pechorin in A Hero of Our TimeA rival at work, a feud with a neighbour, and suddenly every day has an edge. Lermontov's Pechorin calls this life itself.
Why do I enjoy being offended? Father Zosima in The Brothers KaramazovSometimes taking offense feels good, even when you know nobody meant it. Dostoevsky put the question almost word for word in 1880.
Why am I so curious about other people's lives? Plutarch's essay On CuriosityYou want to know what happens behind other people's doors. Plutarch noticed nearly two thousand years ago which doors draw us, and why.
What life asks everyoneSeven questions about time, choice, closeness and meaning. Answer them for yourself and leave with one question.
Why was I happier when I had less? Charles Lamb on the old purchasesIn Lamb's essay "Old China," Bridget misses the years when money was short. She does not miss being poor. She misses how long they used to want things.
Why is looking forward to something better than the thing itself? Johnson's Idler No. 58The trip in your head is always better than the trip. Samuel Johnson noticed why in 1759, and it isn't that the trip was bad.
Why do I want two opposite things at the same time? Augustine on two willsAugustine noticed that the hand obeys the mind at once, while the mind does not obey itself. His explanation is two wills, each missing something the other has.
Why do I stop enjoying things when I have to do them? Mark Twain on the word obligedIn Tom Sawyer, the fence stays the same. Only one word changes, and it decides whether the job is work or play.
Why do I let people talk me out of what I want? Jane Austen on being persuadedIn Persuasion, Anne Elliot is talked out of an engagement by the woman she trusts most. Austen makes no villain of her. The question is whose judgment Anne was using.
Why do I feel more like myself away from home? Hazlitt on going a journeyAway from home you feel lighter and more yourself. William Hazlitt explained why, and it has less to do with the place than with who knows you there.
Why do I fall for flattery? La Rochefoucauld on the flatterer insideYou can see the flattery coming and it still lands. La Rochefoucauld says why: someone got there before the flatterer.
Why do words never say what I mean? Marlow on the deck in Conrad's "Heart of Darkness"You try to explain what you feel, and it comes out flat or wrong. Conrad's Marlow says it cannot be done, and then goes on telling his story to the men in the dark.
Why do I only appreciate things after losing them? The Friar in "Much Ado About Nothing"A flat, a job, a quiet morning: their worth shows only when they are gone. Shakespeare's Friar says it is not indifference that hides the value. It is having.
Why do I lie to myself? Dr Relling and the life-lie in Ibsen's "The Wild Duck"Some stories about ourselves hold a life up. In Ibsen's The Wild Duck, one man props up a friend's illusion and another wants to tear it down. Neither asks the friend.
Why do I break promises to myself? The Player King in "Hamlet"You promise yourself to start on Monday, and by Wednesday it is gone. In Hamlet, the Player King explains why: a purpose made in a strong moment outlives the moment that made it.
Why do I always need to be right? Schopenhauer on the first word in an argumentHalfway through an argument you start to doubt your point and keep defending it anyway. Schopenhauer saw why: we speak before we think, and then we defend what we said.
Why have I become so cynical? Oscar Wilde on the price of everythingWilde defines the cynic in one line and answers him in the next. The answer is about the person the cynic used to be.
Why don't I have my own opinions? Emerson on the crowd and solitudeAlone, you know what you think. In company, you agree with whoever is speaking. Emerson did not see two kinds of people here, only one hard place to stand.
Why do I only know what I think when I say it? Bacon on thoughts in packsAlone, a thought stays vague. Said to someone, it suddenly has a shape. Francis Bacon noticed this four centuries ago and named it the second fruit of friendship.
Why do I only enjoy things if I can tell someone? Pascal's sea voyageSome pleasures seem to finish only when they are told. Pascal asked whether we would travel if we could never speak of it.
Why do I jump from one interest to another? Seneca on everywhere and nowhereA new interest arrives, burns for a few weeks, and gives way to the next. Seneca wrote about books, but his example came from friendship.
Why do I fall for the idea of someone? Stendhal on crystallizationFalling for an image is not simply a mistake about a person. Stendhal described how the mind grows crystals on a bare branch.
Why do I always find reasons for what I already want? Franklin and the codThe decision comes first and the argument arrives right after it. Benjamin Franklin caught himself doing this on a ship and laughed instead of judging.
Why am I afraid of being ordinary? George Eliot on lives not widely visibleThe fear is not of a quiet life. It is of a life nobody notices. George Eliot ended Middlemarch by changing how a life is measured.
Am I too old to start over? Cicero on learning Greek lateThe feeling of being too late rarely comes from the calendar. Cicero's Cato took up Greek as an old man and described it as thirst.
Why do I give advice I don't follow? Portia in The Merchant of VeniceA friend gets clear advice from you, and you live the opposite. Shakespeare's Portia says knowing what is good and doing it are two different skills.
Why do I enjoy disliking people? Hazlitt on the pleasure of hatingA colleague's voice, a relative's opinions. Disliking them can feel oddly good. William Hazlitt noticed what that feeling lets us skip.
Why am I so inconsistent? Montaigne on the inconstancy of our actionsMontaigne noticed he was a different man from one day to the next. He stopped looking for the real one and started looking at what he did.
Why am I drawn to bad influences? Lord Henry in The Picture of Dorian GrayBasil warns Dorian that Lord Henry is a bad influence. A minute later Dorian has taken a fancy to him. The pull is often toward permission.
Why is real life never like I imagined? Emma in Madame BovaryFlaubert's Emma measures her life against words she found in books. When happiness doesn't come, she doubts love, never the words.
Why have I become so boring? Chekhov's IonitchChekhov's doctor Startsev says plainly what has become of him. Saying it changes nothing. The dullness gets made again every evening.
Why do I miss my childhood? Tolstoy's never-returning timeIn Childhood, Tolstoy's boy falls asleep expecting happiness. What an adult misses may be that expectation more than the toys.
Why do I hate owing people? La Rochefoucauld on gratitudeLa Rochefoucauld called the hurry to repay a favor a kind of ingratitude. Paying back fast can be a way out of the bond a gift creates.
Why is it so hard to visit my parents? Bazarov goes homeIn Fathers and Sons, Bazarov is bored and angry at his parents' house. Turgenev shows that the trouble is how he sees himself beside them.
Why do I keep wondering what if? Frost's The Road Not TakenIn the middle of Frost's poem the two roads are worn about the same. The difference only appears later, in the story told with a sigh.
Why do I envy people with simple lives? Olenin in The CossacksTolstoy's Olenin finds the Cossacks beautiful, strong and free, and feels ashamed and sorry for himself. The envy points at his own life.
Why do I enjoy complaining? Dostoevsky's toothacheThe man from Notes from Underground moans about his toothache for an audience that doesn't believe him. A complaint can keep people close without asking anything of them.
Why am I embarrassed of where I come from? Pip's hands in Great ExpectationsPip had never looked at his hands until a girl called them coarse. Dickens shows shame about home arriving ready-made, from someone else's eyes.
Why do I need to hear that they love me? Shakespeare's "King Lear"You know they love you, and still you wait for the words. In the first scene of King Lear a king asks his daughters to say it, and pays for the answer in land.
Why do I make fun of myself in front of others? La Rochefoucauld on small faultsYou joke about your own clumsiness before anyone else can. Three centuries ago, La Rochefoucauld noticed what such confessions are for.
Why am I never satisfied? Goethe's Faust and the bet against contentmentYou get what you wanted, and within a week it isn't enough. Goethe's Faust bets his soul on never being content, as if contentment were the thing to fear.
Who am I underneath all my roles? Ibsen's Peer Gynt and the onionParent, colleague, friend, and somewhere under it all a real you. In Ibsen's play Peer Gynt peels an onion looking for the kernel.
Would I be honest if no one was watching? Plato and the ring of GygesThe ring of Gyges makes a man invisible. Plato tells the story through a speaker who does not believe it. The question it leaves is about the people watching now.
Why have I played it safe my whole life? The buried talentSome people look back and see a life of careful choices. In the parable of the talents, the servant who buries his share describes his master's face before he mentions his fear.
Why does it bother me when someone else is praised? The mirror in "Snowdrop"A colleague gets the compliment, and something in you drops. In the Grimms' tale the glass never calls the queen ugly. It just stops calling her the fairest.
Why do I pretend I didn't want it? Aesop's fox and the grapesAfter a rejection you tell yourself you never wanted it. Aesop's fox says the same, out loud, with no one around to hear.
Why do I want to be known? Prince Andrew's night in "War and Peace"Some wishes feel too embarrassing to say even to yourself. On the eve of Austerlitz, Tolstoy's Prince Andrew admits one, and excuses it in the same breath.
Why do I want it just because it's forbidden? Augustine and the pearsAugustine stole pears he did not want and threw them to the pigs. Sixteen centuries later he is still asking what he wanted instead.
Why do I pretend to understand? Andersen's "The Emperor's New Clothes"Someone explains, everyone nods, and so do you. In Andersen's tale an old minister sees nothing on the loom and decides something about himself first.
Why do I exaggerate when I talk about myself? Gogol's KhlestakovNobody plans to embellish. In Gogol's "The Inspector-General" a small clerk grows bigger with every sentence, and the people listening help him do it.
Did I become what people expected me to be? Lermontov's PechorinPechorin says people saw vices in him that weren''t there, so the vices grew. Lermontov also shows when he says it, and to whom.
Why did I never say I loved them? Chekhov's "About Love"Not every silence comes from fear. In Chekhov's "About Love" a man stays quiet for years, and his reasons are good ones.
Why do I talk about my plans and never act? Turgenev's "Rudin"Some people describe what they will do so well that the doing never starts. Turgenev's Rudin knew this about himself and wrote it down in a letter.
I love humanity but I can't stand people. Dostoevsky's doctorCaring about the world and wincing at the person across the table is an old combination. In The Brothers Karamazov a doctor says exactly what the person in the room takes from him.
I lived my life for someone else. Chekhov's "Uncle Vanya"Years given to someone else's work can turn into a bill nobody agreed to pay. In Chekhov's play the bill arrives after twenty-five years, and it goes to the wrong address.
Why do I shrink around important people? Chekhov's "Fat and Thin"Around someone with more status, some people turn smaller without being asked. In Chekhov's short story the important man refuses the bow, and the bow comes anyway.
Therapy when nothing is wrong: do you need a reason to go?Most pages answer with a list of reasons to book anyway. Irvin Yalom suggests a different question, about what stands in the way rather than what hurts.
Nobody knows the real me. Chekhov's man with two livesThe feeling that nobody knows you is usually taken for loneliness. In Chekhov's "The Lady with the Dog" it is simply how a life is arranged. The question is what you keep hidden.
I moved to a new city but nothing changed. Seneca on fleeing yourselfA new city, a new flat, the same old feeling. Two thousand years ago Seneca described people who change places the way a sick man turns in bed.
Waiting for my real life to start: the Moscow of Chekhov's Three SistersWhy does it feel like life hasn't started yet? In Chekhov's Three Sisters, "real life" has an address. What the play shows about a place you never go to check.
Is it love or just habit? What Pushkin meant by habit in Eugene OneginAfter years together you ask whether this is still love or only habit. Pushkin wrote two lines about habit that are usually read as a joke. In the poem they are about something else.
How did I become the person I used to despise? Chekhov's IonitchNobody decides to become the person they once looked down on. Chekhov's story about a young doctor shows how it happens without a single decision.
Why do I feel guilty for being happy? Chekhov's man with a hammerA good week, and underneath it a quiet guilt. In Chekhov's story "Gooseberries", a man wishes every happy person had someone at the door with a hammer.
Would I live my life again? Nietzsche's demon and the heaviest burdenWhat if you had to live this exact life again, endlessly? Nietzsche put the question in a demon's mouth in 1882. It is less about the past than it looks.
Why do I want someone to tell me what to do? Dostoevsky's Grand InquisitorSometimes the wish is plain: let someone else decide. In The Brothers Karamazov, the Grand Inquisitor calls this the deepest human anxiety, and offers a deal.
Why do I act against my own interest? Dostoevsky's underground manYou know what would be good for you and do the opposite. Dostoevsky's underground man argued that this is not a miscalculation. His answer is about freedom.
Why can't I sit alone with my thoughts? What Pascal saw in diversionA free hour, and the phone is already in hand. Pascal wrote about this in the 1650s, and he did not call it a weakness of will.
Why am I different with different people? William James on the social selfQuiet at home, loud with friends, careful at work. William James described this in 1890 and did not call it fake. He asked a different question.
Why do I keep repeating the same mistakes? What Kierkegaard meant by repetitionThe usual answers are habits and brain wiring. Kierkegaard's Repetition asks a different question, about which way a person is facing when the same choice comes round again.
Telling ChatGPT what you tell no oneWhy it can be easier to say something to a chat window than to a person, what the psychologist Sidney Jourard wrote about being known, and what happens to the words once they are said.
Having time: Heidegger in the Zollikon SeminarsIn 1965 Martin Heidegger asked a room of psychiatrists what they mean when they say "I have no time". What the Zollikon Seminars say about clock time and time for something.
Should I go back to therapy after quitting? Bugental on resistanceYou quit therapy and now wonder about going back. What James Bugental wrote about resistance, and how his chapter looks at the moment someone leaves.
I feel like I'm wasting my life. What Tolstoy's Ivan Ilych asked too lateAdvice on a wasted life usually says to find a goal. Tolstoy's story asks a different question, about whose measure decides what counts as wasted.
Wish and will: Yalom on what comes before a decisionIn Existential Psychotherapy, Irvin Yalom argues that willing begins with wishing, and wishing with feeling. What his chapter "Willing" says about people who cannot say what they want.
Does my life just happen to me? Yalom on responsibilityIn Existential Psychotherapy, Irvin Yalom describes how people hand the authorship of their lives to something else, and where responsibility stops.
Why talk about the therapist in therapy? Yalom's here-and-nowIn The Gift of Therapy, Irvin Yalom argues that what happens between patient and therapist says more than any account of life outside the room.
Why write after a therapy session? Yalom and Ginny ElkinIrvin Yalom and his patient Ginny Elkin each wrote up every hour they spent together. For months neither read the other, and the two records differ.
Umwelt, Mitwelt, Eigenwelt: Rollo May's three modes of worldRollo May described three modes of world that a person lives in at once. What Umwelt, Mitwelt and Eigenwelt mean, and why he said the word adjustment has no place in the second.
Tillich on anxiety: neurosis as avoiding beingIn The Courage to Be, Paul Tillich names three types of anxiety and then describes neurosis as a narrowed life. What his chapter on pathological anxiety says about giving up part of oneself to feel safer.
Ontological guilt: Rollo May on forfeited potentialitiesIn The Discovery of Being, Rollo May describes a guilt that needs no wrongdoing. What he meant by ontological guilt, and why its first form is the guilt of a possibility left unlived.
To be that self which one truly is: Rogers on being a processIn On Becoming a Person, Carl Rogers borrows a phrase from Kierkegaard and describes clients who stop expecting themselves to be finished.
Why is it hard to say it out loud? Foucault on parrhesiaParrhesia is the Greek word for saying everything. In his 1983 Berkeley lectures, Foucault made risk part of what frank speech is.
Anxious with nothing to fear? Rollo May on anxiety vs fearFear has an object. Anxiety, in Rollo May's account, threatens the ground a person stands on. What The Meaning of Anxiety says about the difference.
Where does meaning come from? Frankl's logotherapyViktor Frankl called the will to meaning the primary human motivation. What logotherapy means by meaning, and why no one can hand it to anyone else.
May I be like this? Längle's third fundamental motivationAlfried Längle's existential analysis names four fundamental motivations. The third asks not who I am but whether I am allowed to be it, and whose permission that is.
Anxiety is the dizziness of freedom: what the rest of Kierkegaard's sentence saysKierkegaard's line about the dizziness of freedom is usually quoted in half. In The Concept of Anxiety the sentence goes on, to a freedom that grabs at something finite to steady itself.
Boundary situations: Jaspers on what cannot be solvedKarl Jaspers called them Grenzsituationen, translated as boundary, limit or ultimate situations. What the chapter "Sources of Philosophy" in Way to Wisdom says about the situations no one can change.
Is it safe to talk to AI about your problems?The American Psychological Association answered this in a 2025 health advisory. What it warns about, what it asks of the apps, and how to check an app against it.
Humanistic conscience in Fromm: the voice that goes unheardErich Fromm split conscience in two. One kind speaks for an authority, the other for the person. Why, in Man for Himself, the second is so hard to hear.
Is there meaning in suffering? Frankl's tragic optimismPain, guilt and death do not go away. Viktor Frankl argued for a tragic optimism that keeps them in view, and refused to call it heroic.
Body, mind or spirit? Frankl's dimensional ontologyIs a person body, psyche or spirit? Viktor Frankl answered with a cup and three shadows. The two laws of dimensional ontology from The Will to Meaning.
Why do I feel empty when everything is fine? Yalom's four givensNothing is wrong, and something still is. Irvin Yalom traced that anxiety to four givens: death, freedom, isolation, meaninglessness.
Why do I feel alone even around people? Existential isolationAlone even among close people? Yalom separates three kinds of aloneness. What the third one is, and why he treats it as a fact, not a symptom.
Is self-care more than rest? Foucault's care of the selfBefore "know yourself" came "take care of yourself". Foucault's reading of epimeleia heautou, and why he treated it as work rather than a mood.
The self-and-world construct system: Bugental on resistanceIn The Art of the Psychotherapist, James Bugental reads resistance as the defense of a picture of oneself and the world. What his chapter on resistance says, and why he does not call it hostility.
Why does talking about myself feel hollow? Bugental on presenceYou can talk about yourself for an hour and never be in the room. What James Bugental meant by presence in psychotherapy, and his five levels of it.
The Buber–Rogers dialogue: can therapy be a meeting of equals?In 1957 Carl Rogers asked Martin Buber whether therapy is an I–Thou meeting. Buber answered that the two people in the room are not equals, and cannot be.
An AI chatbot as a therapist: the problem of a conversation that agreesResearch on sycophancy shows that assistants trained on human feedback lean toward what the user already believes. What that means for a conversation about yourself.

English